The All American Award is the highest athletic honor for a high school athlete. Considerations for All-American candidates include:

Year	Name	Status	High School Team	Notes:
2005	Kathryn Bachen	All-American	Bainbridge High School
2005	Erin Coltrera	All-American	Lakeside High School
2005	Christen Toepel	All-American	Bainbridge High School
2005	Anna de Regt	All-American Honorable Mention	Overlake High School
2005	Kate Okrasinski	All-American Honorable Mention	Lakeside High School
2005	Danielle Zorn	All-American Honorable Mention	Mercer Island High School
2004	Jen Utley	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
2004	Mehgan Colkitt	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
2004	Maggie Pettit	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
2004	Kelly Nakata	All-American Honorable Mention	Mercer Island HS
2003	Noelle Anderson	All-American	Panthers-Seattle Prep	Montana
2003	Jessica Verrilli	All-American	Panthers-Seattle Prep	Stanford
2003	Mallory Lobisser	All-American Honorable Mention	Lakeside	Washington & Lee
2002	Hilary Pentz	All-American	Overlake School	Tufts
2002	Christen Faltermeier	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
2002	Jessica Verrilli	All-American Honorable Mention	Panthers	Stanford
2002	Jeni Ellison	All-American Honorable Mention	Overlake School
2001	Lindsay Newlon	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS	Middlebury College
2001	Morgan Turnbow	All-American	Overlake School	Colorado College
2001	Dee Dee Banel	All-American-Honorable Mention	Holy Names Academy	Holy Cross
2001	Maureen Wiley	All-American-Honorable Mention	Lakeside School	Boston College
2001	Caitlin Kiley	Academic All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
2001	Paulina Blackinton	Academic All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
2001	Alysha Perisho	Academic All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
2001	Suzanne replinger	Academic All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
2001	Jaron Santelli	Academic All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
2001	Alex Baker	Academic All-American	Overlake School
2001	Sarah Buchwalter	Academic All-American	Overlake School
2000	Alana Martinez	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
2000	Lindsay Newlon	All-American-Honorable Mention	Bainbridge Island HS
2000	Kirsten Thomas	All-American	Overlake School	Middlebury College
1999	Lillie Cridland	All-American	Lakeside School
1999	Anne Morgan	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
1999	Lisa Lurie	All-American-Honorable Mention	Bainbridge Island HS
1999	Lisa Marshall	All-American-Honorable Mention	Lakeside School
1999	Amy Mizell	All-American-Honorable Mention	Bellevue	In 1999 Amy played 3rd Home and scored 50 goals for NAVY the 1999 NIRSA Champions
1998	Jessica Gigot	All-American-Honorable Mention	Overlake School
1998	Anne Morgan	All-American-Honorable Mention	Bainbridge Island HS
1996	Emily Roberts, Molly Storch, Karen Bech	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
1995	Marina Sheldon	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
1993	Sydney Schuck	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
1991	Darcy MacFarlane	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS
1989	Allison Hohn	All-American	Bainbridge Island HS